JEL State Point

Solids-flux state point analysis for secondary settling tanks. Everything runs in your browser.

Plant average

Worst lane

State point diagram

Solids flux against concentration for one clarifier surface. Underflow lines run from the applied flux on the vertical axis, through the state point, down to the predicted RAS concentration.

Gravity flux (Vesilind) Total flux at current RAS Overflow line (Q/A) Underflow line, average Underflow line, worst lane Critical underflow line (limiting flux)

Loading and limits

QuantityAverageWorst lane

Headroom

How far each lever can move before the clarifiers fail, others held.

LimitAverageWorst lane

Time to overflow

Flows and MLSS held at current values.

BlanketAverageWorst lane

Operating envelope

Maximum forward flow the clarifiers can carry at each MLSS. The lower of the two curves governs.

Thickening limit Clarification limit Current, average Current, worst lane

How it works

Settling model

Zone settling velocity follows Vesilind, Vs = V₀·e−K·X, with X in g/L (= kg/m³). In SVI mode the parameters come from the correlation

V₀ = α·e^(−β·SVI) K = γ + δ·SVI

With the default α–δ and SVI 120 this gives V₀ ≈ 5.6 m/h and K ≈ 0.54 L/g. Use the SVI basis the coefficients were fitted on (SVI, DSVI or SSVI). If your coefficients belong to a different equation form, switch to Direct V₀ & K.

Reading the diagram

  • Gravity flux is G = X·V₀·e−KX: the solids the sludge can carry down by settling alone.
  • The state point sits at MLSS on the overflow line, whose slope is the surface overflow rate q = Q/A.
  • The underflow line has slope −QRAS/A. It cuts the vertical axis at the applied solids flux (Q+QRAS)·X/A and the horizontal axis at the RAS concentration the mass balance predicts.
  • Thickening failure: the underflow line crosses the falling limb of the gravity curve. The clarifier cannot thicken to the RAS concentration demanded, so the blanket rises. The red dashed line is the steepest-allowable case, drawn tangent to the falling limb; its intercept is the limiting flux.
  • Clarification failure: the state point lies above the gravity curve, meaning overflow rate exceeds what the sludge settles at that MLSS.

Time to overflow

In thickening failure the clarifier receives more solids than it can pass to the underflow. The surplus builds a blanket at the limiting concentration XL, sitting under a dilute zone at Xd, where the total flux curve on its rising limb equals the applied flux. The interface between them rises at

dh/dt = (applied flux − limiting flux) / (X_L − X_d)

Time to overflow is the sidewater depth divided by that rate, taking the blanket from the floor to the water surface. Flows and MLSS stay at their current values, so in reality the drawdown of MLSS into the blanket slows the rise and the true time is longer.

Assumptions

  • Steady state. Flow splits evenly across the clarifiers in service. WAS and effluent solids are ignored in the mass balance.
  • The worst-lane factor scales MLSS for the most heavily loaded clarifiers at the same flows. It approximates channel imbalance and does not model the runaway that develops over time.
  • A thickening failure here is an instantaneous verdict. In the plant the blanket stores solids, draws MLSS down and can rebalance. That dynamic is for phase two.
  • If QRAS/A exceeds V₀/e², the total flux curve has no minimum, so thickening does not limit.

JEL State Point © 2026 James Lloyd. Released under the MIT License: free to use, copy, modify and share, provided the copyright and licence notice below is kept with every copy or substantial portion.

Built using Claude (Anthropic). Use the results with caution: they are estimates from a settling model and haven't been independently verified. Check them against your own engineering judgement and plant data, and follow your site's procedures for any operational change. Provided as is, without warranty of any kind; the authors accept no liability for how the results are used.

MIT License
Copyright (c) 2026 James Lloyd

Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy
of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal
in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights
to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell
copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is
furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR
IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM,
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE
SOFTWARE.